MCA Specific Appeals
Many merchants face harsh court rulings that don’t seem right, and the consequences can be life-changing. An unfair decision in a merchant cash advance (MCA) lawsuit can leave your business and finances hanging by a thread. The good news? You may have another chance to fight for justice through what is known as an appeal.
Think of appealing a ruling in a MCA lawsuit as an opportunity to take your case to the next level—a chance to set the record straight. At Colonna Cohen Law, we have seen the toll unfair rulings take on hardworking business owners. That’s why we’re committed to helping you take back control. If you have poured everything into your business, this fight for justice isn’t just about money. It’s about your livelihood and your future.
What Is an Appeal?
An appeal is your opportunity to ask a higher court to review a lower court’s decision. It’s not about re-trying your case or presenting new evidence. Instead, it focuses on whether the court made legal errors that impacted the outcome.
When you appeal, you’re basically saying, “I believe the court made a mistake, and it needs to be corrected.” These mistakes could include misinterpreting the law, applying the wrong legal standard, or failing to consider critical evidence. An appeal allows you to argue that these errors affected the fairness of your case.
Appeals require a different approach than your original case. You won’t be calling witnesses or presenting new facts. Instead, your lawyer will use trial transcripts, court documents, and legal arguments to show the appellate court why the decision should be reversed or changed. Remember: an appeal is about raising specific errors that might have occurred at trial.
Types of Appeals
Not all appeals are the same. Different types of appeals address specific legal situations and serve distinct purposes. Understanding which type of appeal fits your case is crucial to building a strong argument. Let’s discuss the most common types.
1. Civil Appeals
Civil appeals involve disputes between two parties, such as individuals or businesses. These appeals challenge decisions in lawsuits over contracts, property, or other civil matters. For example, if you believe the court misapplied the law in your merchant cash advance (MCA) case, a civil appeal may be your path to justice.
In these cases, the focus is on whether legal errors impacted the outcome, not the facts themselves. Civil appeals require detailed legal arguments to show the appellate court why the original ruling was wrong.
2. Interlocutory Appeals
Sometimes, legal disputes arise during a trial before a final decision is reached. Interlocutory appeals allow you to challenge specific rulings made during the case, such as the admission of certain evidence or a judge’s interpretation of the law.
These appeals are less common because courts generally prefer to resolve issues after the final judgment. However, in high-stakes cases like MCA lawsuits, an interlocutory appeal can prevent irreparable harm if a critical ruling jeopardizes your case.
3. Final Judgment Appeals
A final judgment appeal occurs after a court has reached a final decision in the case. This type of appeal is the most common and allows you to challenge the outcome of the entire trial.
For example, if a court ruled in favor of an MCA lender based on questionable contract terms, a final judgment appeal could help overturn that decision. These appeals focus on legal mistakes that affected the trial’s fairness or outcome.
4. Appeals on Procedural Grounds
These appeals argue that procedural errors—like missed deadlines or improperly filed documents—affected the case. While these issues may seem small, they affect fairness and justice.
You need to understand which type of appeal applies to your case before taking action. At Colonna Cohen Law, we have the experience to identify the best appeal strategy for your situation. If you feel something went wrong in your MCA case, don’t hesitate to reach out to our New York appeals attorney.
The Appeals Process in New York
Appealing a court decision in New York follows a different course than trial cases. Here’s what to expect from this process:
- Filing a Notice of Appeal: This is the first step. A Notice of Appeal informs the court and the opposing party that you intend to challenge the decision. But don’t delay this action as potential appellant generally has 30 days from the date of the decision to file this notice, according to the Supreme Court of the State of New York. Missing this deadline can prevent you from appealing altogether. Your merchant cash advance appeal attorney in New York will ensure it’s filed correctly and on time.
- Preparing the record on appeal: This record should include all documents, evidence, and transcripts from the original trial. The appellate court bases its decision on the trial’s proceedings, not new evidence, which is why this record is an essential part of the appeals process. But gathering and organizing these materials is a meticulous task. Any missing or incomplete documents could weaken your case.
- Submitting briefs: Once the record is complete, both sides submit their legal briefs to the appellate court. These documents outline the arguments for and against the appeal. The appellant’s brief explains the legal errors made in the original trial and argues why the decision should be overturned or modified. The opposing party then files a respondent’s brief, defending the lower court’s ruling. Your brief should provide compelling reasons for the appellate court to rule in your favor.
- Providing oral arguments: Sometimes, the court will schedule oral arguments, where attorneys for both sides present their positions in person. This is an opportunity to emphasize key points from the briefs and answer questions from the judges. Oral arguments are not guaranteed in every case. Whether they occur depends on the court’s discretion and the overall complexity of the appeal.
- Waiting for the appellate decision: After reviewing the briefs, the record, and oral arguments, the appellate court will issue its decision. This process can take months, as judges carefully evaluate the case. The court may (a) affirm the lower court’s decision, leaving it unchanged, (b) reverse the decision, granting a new outcome, (c) modify the decision, adjusting specific aspects of the ruling, or (d) remand the case back to the lower court for further proceedings.
Remember: appealing a decision isn’t a guarantee of success. Appellate courts are cautious about overturning lower court rulings. That’s why you need to make sure you present a strong, well-prepared case.
Types of Appeals in Merchant Cash Advance Lawsuits
When a court ruling feels unjust, an appeal can provide a path to challenge the decision. Below are some common scenarios where appeals frequently arise in MCA lawsuits:
1. Disputes Over Contractual Terms
MCA agreements often contain vague or unfair terms that heavily favor lenders. Courts sometimes enforce these agreements even when they include unreasonable clauses.
For example, if a court ruled that you must repay an MCA despite clear evidence of unconscionable terms, an appeal could challenge that decision. An appellate court may find that the contract’s terms were unfair or improperly applied, potentially reversing the judgment.
2. Fraud Allegations
Fraud claims can arise when either party accuses the other of deceptive practices. In MCA cases, merchants may argue they were misled about the terms of the agreement, while lenders might claim merchants concealed financial issues.
If a court dismissed your fraud claim without properly considering the evidence, you could appeal. The appellate court could review whether the dismissal was justified or whether errors in the legal process affected the outcome.
3. Misclassification of MCA Agreements
One of the most contested issues in MCA lawsuits is whether the agreement qualifies as a loan or a sales transaction. Lenders argue that MCAs are sales of future receivables, while merchants often claim they function as loans, subject to usury laws.
If a court took the lender’s side and refused to classify the agreement as a loan, you might have grounds to appeal. An appeal could focus on whether the court applied the correct legal standard in determining the classification.
4. Judgment Enforcement Issues
MCA lenders often seek judgments to enforce repayment terms, sometimes relying on aggressive and inappropriate collection practices. If a court ruled against you in a judgment enforcement case, you could appeal to challenge the methods or evidence used to secure the judgment. For instance, if the lender provided inaccurate financial records or the court failed to account for disputed amounts, an appeal could highlight these errors.
5. Procedural Errors During the Trial
Trials are governed by strict procedural rules. If these rules are violated, it can impact the fairness of the outcome. In MCA lawsuits, procedural errors might involve misinterpretation of evidence, improper jury instructions, or exclusion of key testimony. For example, if the court improperly excluded evidence that could have supported your defense, you could appeal on the grounds of a procedural error.
6. Conflicts with State or Federal Laws
MCA agreements often operate in a gray area of the law, which is why disputes over whether they comply with state or federal regulations aren’t unheard of. If a court failed to address these conflicts or misapplied the law, you might appeal to seek a more accurate ruling. For instance, you could challenge a decision that failed to consider state usury laws in a case involving high-interest charges.
Why Merchants Need a New York Appeals Attorney
In a MCA lawsuit, the stakes are always high, with your financial stability and business future hanging in the balance. When a court decision doesn’t go your way, an appeal may be your best chance to set things right.
But appeals aren’t easy. They require a deep understanding of the law, strict adherence to court rules, and the ability to craft persuasive arguments. This is where you might need to work with a merchant cash advance attorney in New York. Here’s why:
- Appeals are not retrials, remember? Many merchants mistakenly believe an appeal is a second chance to present their side of the story. But appeals are not retrials. They focus on legal errors made in the original case, not new evidence or testimony. A lawyer understands this distinction and knows how to identify and argue the specific issues that could change the outcome of your case.
- MCA lawsuits are uniquely challenging. Lenders often include complex terms in their agreements, pushing the limits of contract law, state usury laws, and even fraud statutes. Appeals in MCA cases require a lawyer who understands these nuances and can effectively argue them before a higher court.
- Appeals are governed by strict deadlines and procedural rules. Missing a filing deadline or failing to include necessary documents could result in your case being dismissed. A New York appeals attorney knows the timelines and requirements inside and out. They will ensure your Notice of Appeal is filed on time, your brief is compelling, and your case is presented in the strongest possible way.
- You want to succeed, don’t you? Appeals are your chance to correct legal errors and secure a fair outcome. But success isn’t guaranteed. It takes an attorney with the skills, experience, and determination to navigate the process and advocate for you effectively.
If you feel the court got it wrong, don’t lose hope. An appeal could be your path to a better outcome. At Colonna Cohen Law, we help merchants challenge unjust decisions in MCA lawsuits. We understand the stress and uncertainty you’re facing, which is why we will do whatever it takes to protect what matters most. Schedule a consultation and discuss your case with our merchant cash advance appeal attorney in New York by calling 917-740-2077 or reaching out via our website.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Merchant Cash Advance Appeals in NYC
An appeal in an MCA lawsuit is a legal process where a higher court reviews a lower court’s decision. It is not a retrial but focuses on identifying and correcting legal errors that may have impacted the outcome. Basically, appeals challenge the fairness and legality of the original decision, not the facts of the case.
You can file an appeal after the lower court issues a final judgment in your case. If the decision is based on procedural errors, misinterpretation of the law, or unjust application of contract terms, filing an appeal may be an appropriate course of action. Parties to civil suits, including MCA litigation, have 30 days from the judgment date to file an appeal.
The most common grounds for appeal include:
- Errors in interpreting or applying the law
- Procedural mistakes, such as mishandling evidence or improper jury instructions
- Unfair enforcement of contract terms
- Misclassification of the MCA agreement as a sales transaction instead of a loan
Consider consulting with an attorney to identify specific errors in the trial record to build a strong appeal.
Yes, you can appeal a default judgment. However, this requires an extra step as you will need to show valid reasons for failing to appear or respond to the original lawsuit. Common reasons include improper service of process, excusable neglect, or other factors that made it impossible for you to defend yourself in the case.
In New York, you generally have 30 days from the date of the judgment or decision to file a Notice of Appeal. If you miss this deadline, you could end up losing your right to appeal.
Don’t be mistaken. Filing an appeal does not automatically stop enforcement actions, such as levies or garnishments. However, your attorney can request a stay of enforcement, which temporarily halts these actions while the appeal is pending. A stay is not guaranteed and may require additional motions or conditions, such as posting a bond.
While challenging a COJ is difficult, it’s not impossible. If you believe the COJ was signed under fraudulent circumstances, duress, or misrepresentation, you may have grounds to appeal or vacate the judgment. Not sure if you have grounds? An attorney can evaluate your specific situation and advise you on your options.
Predatory lending practices, such as excessive fees or misleading contract terms, often form the basis for MCA appeals. If your agreement included unreasonable or illegal terms, such as violating state usury laws, your attorney could argue that the original judgment was based on an unfair or invalid contract. These arguments tend to be particularly compelling in appeals.
No, appeals are limited to the evidence and records presented in the original trial. The appellate court reviews the trial record to determine if legal errors were made. If you have new evidence and wish to present it to the court, it may require filing a motion for a new trial in the lower court, not an appeal.
Reversing and remanding are two possible outcomes of an appeal. Reversing occurs when an appellate court overturns the lower court’s decision entirely, resulting in a new outcome, such as dismissing the case or ruling in favor of the appellant. Remanding, on the other hand, is when the appellate court sends the case back to the lower court for further proceedings, often with specific instructions to correct legal errors or reconsider certain aspects of the case.
Yes, you can appeal enforcement orders if they were issued improperly or based on a flawed judgment. A merchant cash advance attorney in New York can help you challenge the legality of the orders and seek relief through the appellate court. These appeals may also involve requesting a stay of enforcement to prevent further actions during the process.
An interlocutory appeal challenges a court’s decision made during the trial, rather than waiting for a final judgment. In MCA cases, this might involve appealing a ruling on the admissibility of evidence or a motion to dismiss. Interlocutory appeals are rare and only allowed under specific circumstances where waiting for a final decision could cause irreparable harm.
Contact Us Now
If your business is struggling with Merchant Cash Advance lawsuits, frozen accounts, UCC liens or collection actions, please contact Colonna Cohen Law to provide relief and protect your livelihood.
